HMIShelf vs P-series goods-to-person
Side-by-side comparison of HMIShelf (Fetch Robotics Inc. (acquired by Zebra Technologies 2021)) and P-series goods-to-person (Beijing Geekplus Technology Co., Ltd.) — specs, pricing, Robo Index, and verified deployments. Updated daily.
Optimize comparison for buyer
Optimized for Manufacturing buyers. Priority specs lifted to the top and marked with a target.
Layer 1: Identity & Trust
Manufacturer Country
- HMIShelfUnited States
- P-series goods-to-personChina
Year First Available
- HMIShelf2014
- P-series goods-to-person2015
Verified Deployments
- HMIShelf0 Deployments
- P-series goods-to-person0 Deployments
Layer 2: Operational
Price
- HMIShelf$38,000 USD
- P-series goods-to-person$28,260 USD
Availability Status
- HMIShelfACTIVE
- P-series goods-to-personACTIVE
Payload & Form Factor
Payload
- HMIShelf78 kg
- P-series goods-to-person500 kg
AMR Subtype
- HMIShelfgoods to person
- P-series goods-to-persongoods to person
Robot Weight
- HMIShelf—
- P-series goods-to-person195 kg
Navigation & Sensing
Navigation Type
- HMIShelfslam natural
- P-series goods-to-personother
Battery
Battery Chemistry
- HMIShelfli ion
- P-series goods-to-personother
Commercial
Price (USD)
- HMIShelf$38,000 USD
- P-series goods-to-person$28,260 USD
Warranty
- HMIShelf1 yrs
- P-series goods-to-person—
| ||
|---|---|---|
| Layer 1: Identity & Trust | ||
| Manufacturer Country (values differ) | United States | China |
| Year First Available (values differ) | 2014 | 2015 |
| Verified Deployments | 0 Deployments | 0 Deployments |
| Layer 2: Operational | ||
| Price (values differ) | $38,000 USD | $28,260 USD |
| Availability Status | ACTIVE | ACTIVE |
| Layer 3: Category Specific | ||
| Payload & Form Factor | ||
| Payload (priority for Manufacturing buyers) (values differ) | 78 kg | 500 kg |
| AMR Subtype | goods to person | goods to person |
| Robot Weight (values differ) | — | 195 kg |
| Navigation & Sensing | ||
| Navigation Type (values differ) | slam natural | other |
| Battery | ||
| Battery Chemistry (values differ) | li ion | other |
| Commercial | ||
| Price (USD) (values differ) | $38,000 USD | $28,260 USD |
| Warranty (values differ) | 1 yrs | — |
Insufficient data for full comparison
The following fields had no data for any of the selected robots: Battery / Shift Runtime, Length, Width, Turning Radius, Min Aisle Width, Ground Clearance, Localization Accuracy, Docking Repeatability, Obstacle Detection Range, Min Object Detection Height, Pedestrian Detection, Max Speed (Loaded), Max Speed (Unloaded), Picks / Hour / Robot, Battery Capacity, Runtime (Loaded), Charging Time, Opportunity Charging, Auto Docking, Battery Swap, Charge Cycles (Rated), ISO 3691-4 Certified, R15.08 Certified, Safety Category, Emergency Stops, Safety LiDAR Coverage, Safety Zone Count, Audible Alert, WMS Integrations, API Type, Fleet Size Supported, Multi-Robot Traffic Mgmt, OTA Updates, Cybersecurity Certs, MTBF, Uptime SLA, Predictive Maintenance, Field Service Response, Spare Parts Lead Time, RaaS / Month, Pricing Models, Expected Service Life
ROI Comparison
Same operating assumptions across every robot — the only difference is price. Set your numbers once to see which pays back fastest.
Annual labor displaced (per robot): $50,000
| Metric | HMIShelf | P-series goods-to-person |
|---|---|---|
| Investment | $38,000 | $28,260 |
| Payback period | 9.1 mo | 6.8 mo |
| Net savings (5 yr) | $212,000 | $221,740 |
| ROI (5 yr) | +558% | +785% |
Estimates labor-cost displacement only — not a full total cost of ownership. Actual ROI depends on integration, maintenance, training, downtime, and task fit. Converted currencies are indicative; USD is the price of record.
Trade-offs at a glance
Frequently asked
Who makes HMIShelf and P-series goods-to-person?
HMIShelf is made by Fetch Robotics Inc. (acquired by Zebra Technologies 2021), based in US. P-series goods-to-person is made by Beijing Geekplus Technology Co., Ltd., based in CN.
When were HMIShelf and P-series goods-to-person launched?
HMIShelf launched in 2014. P-series goods-to-person launched in 2015.
How do HMIShelf and P-series goods-to-person compare on the Robo Index?
HMIShelf grades A on the Robo Index. P-series goods-to-person grades AA. The Robo Index is a credibility grade (AAA … C) that blends commercial maturity, verified deployments, company standing, and independent coverage — see methodology for the full breakdown.
Are HMIShelf and P-series goods-to-person in the same category?
Both robots are classified as Amr Warehouse on Robolist. Filters and ranking treat them as direct alternatives.
What is the realistic total cost of ownership for Amr Warehouse robots?
Hardware cost is one input. Amr Warehouse TCO also includes integration, training, downtime, and end-of-life. Our breakdown: AMR TCO: Fleet Size, Charging Infrastructure, and WMS Integration.
What should a buyer ask vendors when choosing between HMIShelf and P-series goods-to-person?
Spec sheets only show part of the story. Useful vendor questions cover support, lifecycle, integration cost, and references. We have a buyer-focused checklist: AMR Vendor Selection: Orchestration, Integration, and Scaling.
Going deeper — picking the right robot
AMR TCO: Fleet Size, Charging Infrastructure, and WMS Integration
8 min readWarehouse AMRs
AMR Vendor Selection: Orchestration, Integration, and Scaling
9 min readWarehouse AMRs
AMR Pilot in an Existing Warehouse: The 90-Day Playbook
9 min readWarehouse AMRs
Build vs buy vs lease: which model fits a first deployment
8 min readChoosing Your First Robot
The hidden specs vendors hope you'll miss
10 min readReading the Spec Sheet
Want to be notified when specs or pricing change for these robots? Drop your email.
Other comparisons
About this comparison
HMIShelf vs P-series goods-to-person compares two robots in the amr-warehouse category. All data is sourced from manufacturer spec sheets, verified deployments, and third-party filings; see our methodology for how the Robo Index is calculated.